Abe Lincoln - Mystery Writer

A Stodghill Says So blog:


Abraham Lincoln's name has been bandied about quite freely of late, thanks to Barack Obama. While most literate people throughout the world know that Honest Abe had few if any peers when it comes to writing speeches, only a handful are aware that he was a mystery writer. Abe, a great admirer of the works of Edgar Allan Poe, entered the field in 1846 when the Trailor Murder Mystery was first published. In 1952 it was reprinted in Ellery Queen's Mystery Magazine and again in 1977 in Murder Ink.
The story began: In the year 1841, there resided at different points in the State of Illinois, three brothers by the name of Trailor. Their Christian names were William, Henry and Archibald. Archibald resided at Springfield, then as now the seat of government of the State. He was a sober, retiring, and industrious man, of about thirty years of age; a carpenter by trade, and a bachelor, boarding with his partner in business - a Mr. Myers.
Now far be it from me, being the kindly, uncritical gentleman that I am, to criticize the work of another writer, but that is not the most scintillating beginning to a mystery I have ever read. I feel quite safe in saying that had it been submitted to Ellery Queen as having been written by Joe Blow from Kokomo it would have quickly moved from the slush pile to an envelope marked return to sender. That would have been true even had the editors not discovered that despite the title there actually was no murder involved. The final paragraphs revealed that the supposed victim had gone nuts and was found aimlessly wandering about.
Another of the great presidents, Franklin Delano Roosevelt, was an avid reader of mysteries, so he too tried his hand at writing them. He couldn't come up with an ending so he sent the manuscript to six prominent writers of the day. Each wrote an ending and the result was published in 1939 in Liberty magazine. Twenty-eight years later it was published in book form with yet another ending by Earle Stanley Gardner.
The moral of the story is that presidents should stick to presidenting and let mystery writers do the writing. The field is crowded enough as it is.

I never knew that about Lincoln or FDR, Dick. Thanks for fulfilling my "learning one new thing every day" attempt.

Quote :

The moral of the story is that presidents should
stick to presidenting and let mystery writers do the writing. The field
is crowded enough as it is.

True, unless their title is something like, "How I Became President". THAT is a mystery.

DIck,

Is there anything you have not heard of?

You are a walking talking book of facts.

I adore Lincoln and this is news to me.
Thanks!

I think you are right about presidents sticking to what they know. And hopefully they know how to run a country, not just how to win elections.

Margaret Truman.

lin wrote:

Margaret Truman.

Explain please

I dunno, Prez' daughter becomes big-selling mystery writer.

By the way, the opening graph Dick cited there doesn't read all that different from some I've seen. Ross Thomas, for example.

So when are we going to have a writer for President?????

Hungary and Peru gave it a shot.

Ross Thomas, a great one I hadn't thought about for a while. Thanks for reminding me, Lin.
I don't like Margaret Truman's boobs so I ignored here.

Dick Stodghill wrote:

Ross Thomas, a great one I hadn't thought about for a while. Thanks for reminding me, Lin.
I don't like Margaret Truman's boobs so I ignored here.

Dick,

Did you really mean this?

It doesn't sound like you.

Oh no! The one time I didn't read over a post and this happens. It's BOOKS - BOOKS - BOOKS.
Actually it does sound like me, but it was unintentional.

Don't crawfish, Dick. If you don't like her boobs, then just stick to your guns. (HA)

It is one of the`funniest things I ever saw!

It was a real blooper!

We should have a contest.

Never met a man who didn't like women's boobs. I've led such a sheltered life.

You sound like my husband, Don. "I'll take it; you don't need to wrap it."

Well, we open the present and throw away the paper anyway. Might as well cut out the waste.